Stepping up
to the plate. It’s a baseball reference, to be sure, but these
days it’s batted around wherever there is a challenge, let alone
the crisis-within-a-crisis that nursing faces today.
No one, except
for RNs themselves, can hit a home run in solving Crisis One:
the well-publicized shortage of nurses, or Crisis Two: the shortage
of nurses with advanced training. Nonetheless, hospitals, educators
and politicians are stepping up to the plate to take a swing at
the twin problems.
Closest to
the action in Congress is Rep. Lois Capps, D-Calif., herself a
nurse for 41 years. Capps, MS, RN, sponsors the Nurse Reinvestment
Act, which among other things proposes a National Nurse Service
Corps that would place nurses in needy communities in exchange
for scholarships. In the six weeks after it was introduced April
4, the bill collected 102 House co-sponsors.
Sen. Tim Hutchinson,
R-Ark., and Sen. John Kerrey, D-Mass., and Sen. James Jeffords,
a former Republican and now an Independent from Vermont, are sponsors
of similar bills, S.721 and S.706, respectively.
"Technology
is making the world of health care so different that unless nurses
are getting degrees or being certified, they get out-of-date really
quickly," said Fay Bower, DNSc, MSN, RN, chair of the department
of nursing at Holy Names College in Oakland, Calif.
The small
Catholic college offers an RN-to-BSN curriculum and a master’s
degree-level family nurse practitioner program.
Higher education
is a nursing expectation and hope, but it can’t be forced, Bower
pointed out.
It can be—and
is being—encouraged, however. Consider the initiatives of hospitals,
which employ 59 percent of all RNs, to grow the nursing workforce
both in quantity and quality.
Five facilities
since 1999 have partnered with Fresno (Calif.) City College in
what is called the Paradigm Program, an intensive 18-month course
leading to an associate degree, said Carolyn Drake, Ed.D., MSN,
RN, the college’s dean of nursing.
The hospitals
pay for theory classes and use their own employees and facilities
for clinical instruction, all the while massaging work schedules
to accommodate employee-students and maintaining their fringe
benefits.
The partnership,
drawing on respiratory therapists, laboratory technicians and
others who may have never dreamed of becoming RNs, has produced
about 70 nurses besides those enrolled in the college’s regular
nursing classes, Drake said. Some have continued on to earn BSN
degrees at California State University, Fresno.
The program
has been a great marketing tool for hospitals, Drake said, and
is evidence of what Bower sees as a new attitude among employers:
"Look, I’ll help you with your career. I’ll help you with
your education."
That attitude
also extends to RN certifications issued by professional organizations.
"A certification in a specialty really does say, ‘I have
the knowledge and experience,’ " said Wanda Johanson, MN,
RN, chief executive officer of the American Association of Critical-Care
Nurses. "It’s another way to reassure patients."
The association
represents 65,000 intensive care unit and emergency room nurses.
Beyond certifications through rigorous testing, it contributes
about $150,000 a year for scholarships leading to BSN and MSN
degrees, Johanson said.
Christine
Kovner, Ph.D., MSN, director of nursing at New York University,
said she considers a baccalaureate degree, with its sociology
and psychology courses in addition to the physical sciences, essential
in today’s environment of older and higher-acuity patients.
In keeping
with that belief, the New York City university has an arrangement
with certain associate degree programs, which guarantees that
RNs who meet a minimum grade point average can transfer into the
BSN program at NYU, Kovner said.
About 1.1
million nurses, or 40 percent of all RNs, entered nursing through
an associate degree program, according to the National Sample
Survey of Registered Nurses, March 2000. That compares with 308,000,
or 19 percent of RNs, in 1980.
About 792,000
RNs, or 29.3 percent, reported entering with a baccalaureate degree,
up from 288,000, or 17.3 percent, in 1980, according to the survey
compiled every four years by the Health Resources and Services
Administration, a division of the U.S. Department of Health and
Human Services.
The trend
toward academic degrees has come at the expense of diploma programs,
however. The survey counted about 800,000 diploma nurses, or 29.6
percent of RNs. By comparison, the 1980 survey showed about 1
million diploma nurses, or 63 percent of all licensed RNs.
About 15.5
percent of nurses had completed academic training beyond basic
RN education, the survey also reported. "In most instances,
the highest level achieved was a baccalaureate degree," the
survey said.
So, nursing
schools have gone elsewhere for graduate students. Namely, they
have made it possible for early- and mid-career professionals
from other disciplines to step into advanced nursing. NYU reports
that 38 percent of its nursing students already have a college
degree.
The University
of California, San Francisco, has had a program for non-nursing
degree students since 1991 and recently expanded it to 60 students
per class, said Janet Coffman, associate director of workforce
policy at the university’s Center for the Health Professions.
"The
first year is a compressed basic nursing curriculum to get the
student ready to take the nursing licensure exam," Coffman
said. "The [next] two years are then master’s level education
and advanced practice specialties, such as nurse practitioner
and nurse-midwife, and some clinical specialties such as geriatrics."
Vanderbilt
University in Nashville, Tenn., also is highly regarded for assimilating
those from other disciplines into nursing graduate programs, Coffman
said.
A master’s
degree in administration prepares nurses for managing large and
small operations, from hospital units to home health and ambulatory
care settings, Bower said. Overall, though, at the master’s level,
"the biggest and hottest specialty is nurse practitioner,"
she said. "They’re blossoming all over the United States,"
with specialties in family, obstetrics, pediatrics, geriatrics
and adult care.
The bottom
line, of course, is economics.
"In this
managed care environment, if physicians can’t see lots of patients
in a short period of time, they can’t make the living they used
to make," Bower said. "So they use nurse practitioners
to take care of primary care. A nurse practitioner and a physician
working together can double the workload."
Statistically,
the registered nurse survey found 88,186 nurse practitioners,
an increase of more than 27 percent from 1996. The number of nurse
practitioners who also are clinical nurse specialists increased
to 14,643, or nearly 88 percent more than in 1996.
Still, the
demand for nurses, particularly advanced practice nurses, is such
that Allied Consulting Inc., the nation’s leading recruiter of
hospital personnel other than physicians, is out of the RN business
except in special cases, said Curtis Pryor, vice president of
the Irving, Texas-based firm.
"It’s
a no-win situation. There are just not enough of them out there,"
he said.
The American
Association of Colleges of Nursing in Washington found that enrollment
at its 556 institutions in the fall was down 2.1 percent from
the previous year, the sixth consecutive year of decline. "There
is a lot of opportunity … out there," said Robert Rosseter,
the association’s director of public affairs. "A lot of people
have the image that all nurses do is the horrible jobs in the
hospital."
The government
survey listed the United States with 2,696,540 licensed RNs. Even
though that is an increase of 5.4 percent from 1996, it’s the
lowest rate of increase ever, the survey said. In the previous
four-year period, from 1992 to 1996, the number of RNs increased
14.2 percent to 2,558,874.
From his vantage
point as a recruiter, Pryor said that three factors would relieve
the shortage: