|
Today's obituaries aren't what they used
to be. Nellie Bradley passed away peacefully in her
bed March 11 at an English nursing home. At 112 years,
she was the oldest living Briton.
Two days later, Delvina Dahlheimer died in Elk River,
Minn., at age 113.
Maud Farris-Luse died in a Michigan hospital March
18 from complications of pneumonia. She had seven children
and outlived six. She had cared for herself until 1991,
when she broke a hip and moved into a nursing home.
She left behind a Guinness World Record as the oldest
verifiable living person. She lived for 115 years and
56 days.
We are getting older, living longer and changing the
face of health care. According to a January California
Healthline report, 20 percent of Americans will be 65
or older by 2030. Older adults now account for 60 percent
of adult ambulatory primary care visits, 80 percent
of home care visits, 48 percent of hospital patients
and 85 percent of nursing home residents, according
to the John A. Hartford Foundation Institute for Geriatric
Nursing at New York University.
Such weighty numbers spark concern about having enough
nurses to care for the aging patient population. "I
think we are 20 years behind," said Gracie Wishnia,
Ph.D., MSN, RN, an associate professor at Spalding University
in Louisville, Ky.
The numbers keep growing. "This is going to be
the demographic group driving the economy," said
Susan Scanland, MSN, GNP, RN, president of Geriscan
Geriatric Consulting in Clarks Summit, Pa.
And the nation needs specialists. The California Healthline
report notes that the country needs 36,000 geriatricians-far
more than the 9,000 now working.
The Hartford Institute reports that only 0.005 percent
of the nation's RNs are certified gerontological nurses.
Some point to poor image as a root cause. "There
are no television shows demonstrating the exciting and
dramatic profession of gerontological nursing,"
said Carol Baird, DNS, RN, an assistant professor at
Purdue University. "Grade school, high school and
college students want to be part of the excitement and
quick pace-assess and cure in 15 minutes or less on
TV-that gerontological nursing does not offer."
These statistics raise questions about patient care,
nurse training, age bias and the price tag on geriatrics.
Gaps in patient care
"Because of the shortage of gerontological nurses,
long-term care facilities are understaffed," Baird
said. "The care and safety of the elderly in long-term
care may be in jeopardy." The shortage can cause
shorter hospital stays, problems with health care assessment,
and patient discharge and rehospitalizations that could
have been prevented.
"There are very few geriatricians," Baird
said. "Elderly are cared for by family practitioners
or internists who generally do a good job," but
geriatricians are more attuned to older adults and the
newest, safest treatments for chronic disease. They
often spend more time with the patient's family to determine
the appropriate actions.
The situation led Scanland to start her consulting
company after years as a nurse practitioner. She found
that medical schools offered physicians little geriatrics
training. "There were tremendous gaps in geriatrics
assessment and management."
Education suffers
Experts agree that gerontological education has suffered.
"I don't know how well the educational system is
dealing with the geriatrics population," said Lori
Costa, MSEd, RN, a lawyer and regulatory consultant
for the California Association of Homes and Services
for the Aging.
Simply put, "The educational process hasn't caught
up with the proliferation of the specialty," said
Shirley Travis, Ph.D., RN, professor of nursing and
president of the National Gerontological Nursing Association.
"Lots of nurses say 'I work with older people,
therefore I'm a gerontological nurse.' " But the
field requires special training, and NGNA advocates
certification.
That happens through the American Nurses Credentialing
Center, Baird said. RNs can take a gerontological specialist
exam, and advanced practice nurses can be certified
as clinical specialists in gerontological nursing or
as gerontological nursing practitioners.
"However, many nurses are caring for the elderly
without graduate degrees," Baird said. "Nurses
often learn on the job, sometimes from nurses who do
not practice the best gerontological nursing."
Travis said that the NGNA's mission is to maintain
"high-quality clinical care of older people, regardless
of the setting." Gerontological nurses work in
varied environments, bringing numerous specialties to
the field-acute, critical, long-term, primary and home
health care.
"But we'd like gerontology to be at least a subspecialty
within their specialty," she said.
Most specialized gerontological education occurs at
the graduate level, Travis said. "Many, but not
all, undergraduate nursing programs have some gero nursing
content." That training can take three forms: didactic
courses of theory, theory combined with clinical experience
or gerontology integrated into the regular program-for
example, looking at a particular disease among young
people, middle-aged and older people.
Gerontological courses cover a wide range: assessment,
functional capacity, quality of life, chronic illness,
long-term care, ethics, finances and daily living activities.
Geriatric patients' needs differ from others, and nurses
must "recognize the older adult is a different
species," said Wishnia, who teaches gerontology.
"I do a whole unit on housing for the older adult,"
covering chronic illness at home, caregiving, depression,
losing touch with society and dementia, Wishnia said.
For example, "Women do better than men at living
alone with chronic illness," she said, perhaps
because many women have spent their lives raising children,
organizing households and adapting to new circumstances.
Sometimes, older patients present atypical signs of
disease, Travis said, such as fever that doesn't occur
in younger patients. Medications differ, too. "The
body doesn't use medications the same way that it does
when you're younger," she said.
Continuing education is key for geriatrics nurses,
Scanland said, but budgets are tight. It also varies
regionally. "There are differences between states
and whether RNs need continuing education to maintain
their licenses," she said. "If it's not required,
it might not be budgeted.
Mary Anne Filo, MS, RN, a nurse educator for the Milwaukee
County Department on Aging, said most of the 50-plus
population has at least one long-term illness. "Eighty
percent of all health care is managing chronic health
care problems. That's a pretty high statistic,"
she said.
Age biases
Gerontology and Alzheimer's care are "pretty much
the wave of the future," said Susan Gilster, RN,
executive director of the Alois Alzheimer Center in
Cincinnati. Wherever nurses are, "they're going
to be working with older adults," she said. But
the field isn't as glamorous as others. "As a society,
I'm not sure how much we value aging," Gilster
said.
It's a common sentiment. "I think the age bias
is terrible," Costa said. "It's kind of like
they're all lumped into this big 'aged' group,"
and not seen as individuals. "We're not a culture
that values the aged like some of the Eastern cultures.
People are very impatient with the aged."
For example, Costa recently heard of an elderly man
with bypass surgery, and her instinctive reaction was,
"What are we doing?" Then she immediately
thought, "Now wait a minute, you don't even know
this person." In this society, "people key
in to the age rather than the condition of the person."
Ethical questions
That can raise ethical questions, too. Travis pointed
to the example of a 90-year-old man who refused to sign
a DNR order. The patient was fully cogent. "It
was just a perfect example," she said, because
it veered from previous notions that 70, 80 or 90 was
the end of the road. "Our life spans are so variable,"
she said. "There can be a 90-year-old who's very
vibrant and vital."
Today, some older adults can be cured, particularly
when health problems relate to conditions that can change:
stress, weight, inadequate housing, abuse. Baird said
that gerontological nurses also help patients live with
chronic conditions such as arthritis, heart disease,
renal insufficiency and neurological difficulties.
Christine Peterson, NP, works in a Philadelphia primary
care office that serves seniors who "would benefit
much if we could teach them to understand their medical
condition and how they can live with it successfully
and how behavioral choices they make may make it better
or worse." Her practice is piloting a program to
do just that.
It's part of a philosophical change. Should an 88-year-old
woman get a mammogram? Such decisions should be based
first on patient preference, and second on patient function,
Scanland said. "Look at the whole person and not
just the age."
Travis agreed. "Limiting care just because someone
is over the chronological age of 65 is no longer acceptable.
As the boomers reach retirement age, the concept of
limiting care based solely on some arbitrary age will
seem ridiculous."
Cost of care
All of that, of course, costs money. "Over 80
percent of the health care dollar spent on a patient
is often spent in the last 20 days of life when the
individual is on life support," Peterson said.
"As a society, we need to devote more effort to
educating people of all ages to discuss and write down
their wishes and feelings regarding life support."
Sometimes, families try to do "too much"
for a dying relative whose outcome won't change, she
said. "The nation's health care money is misspent,
and mom suffers."
Peterson is writing a book for families of seniors
with chronic disease. "Efforts like this can shift
the way health care dollars are spent," she said.
Still, problems persist. "This year, many states
are near financial catastrophe and are not planning
for the future," Baird said.
Older patients and longer life spans mean more long-term
care needs. "There is no answer to the financial
quagmire in sight."
Despite the difficulties, gerontological nurses stress
the rewards of working with the aged. Such patients
offer a wealth of life experience, and gerontological
nurses can develop long-term relationships with older
adults and their families.
"I wish somehow we could really emphasize to nurses
the rewards you get from working with the elderly patient
and the chronic patient," Costa said. Long-term
care offers nurses the opportunity to do what they do
best, caring for people. "It personifies nursing,"
she said.
Contact Karen J. Coates at redcoates@hotmail.com.
|