Tara Miller,
22, was living in a shelter for pregnant women when she walked
into Barbara Hughes’ midwifery clinic. Before long, the Colorado
clinic became Miller’s second home.
Hughes, MBA,
MS, RN, CNM, and her fellow midwives counseled Miller about her
rocky relationship with the baby’s father and connected the expectant
mother with local food pantries and clothing outlets.
When the father
showed up for the delivery, Hughes knew the birth could be instrumental
for the struggling couple. Hughes asked the father if he would
help with the delivery.
"He was
crying by the time the baby was out," Hughes said. "It
was such a beautiful, powerful experience."
For Hughes,
nurse-midwifery gives her a freedom that hospital obstetric units
can’t deliver. Rather than focusing solely on the birth, she prefers
to work with women from the early months of pregnancy through
to the delivery. Midwifery also allows her to continue working
with women long after the end of their pregnancies.
This field
of nursing has been growing rapidly, with a 25 percent increase
in certified nurse-midwives per year since 1991, according to
the American College of Nurse-Midwives.
Hughes, one
of 7,000 certified nurse-midwives throughout the nation, started
her nursing career in a hospital labor and delivery unit. But
she didn’t enjoy relinquishing the final delivery moment to physicians.
"When
you establish a rapport with a woman after spending time with
her, and someone else walks in and catches the baby, that leaves
something missing," Hughes said.
After two
years in the unit, she returned to school for two years to become
a certified nurse-midwife. But she had an even bigger dream of
opening her own clinic. To gain business savvy, she earned an
MBA. Three years ago, she opened Aurora Nurse-Midwives, a clinic
of 15 nurse-midwives and two obstetricians.
Hughes wanted
to open her clinic to women who were on Medicaid or who had no
insurance. All nurse-midwives on staff are bilingual.
"Instead
of being treated like a number, I felt like I was giving birth
in front of family," Miller said. "Barbara seemed to
be almost at my beck and call, and she was there the whole time
during the delivery."
Hughes constantly
is met with the misconception that midwives commonly perform deliveries
in the home.
About
96 percent of the deliveries by certified nurse-midwives take
place in hospitals, according to the ACNM.
Insurance
providers in some states also can be reluctant to cover nurse-midwives
who run their practices independently, according to nurse-midwives.
Hughes avoided these problems because her clinic is owned by a
large health care company that has clout when negotiating with
providers.
Like Hughes,
B.J. Snell, Ph.D., a women’s health care nurse practitioner, was
drawn to nurse-midwifery because she wanted to work with women
in all stages of pregnancy and life. She was a perinatal clinical
nurse specialist for six years and then a neonatal ICU nurse for
six years, but she grew increasingly disillusioned.
"The
model was to treat all women as high-risk until they had proved
otherwise," she said. "I was frustrated with a system
that treated a healthy life transition as a disease. The midwifery
philosophy is to trust in a woman’s ability to give birth."
This difference
in approach is reflected in national statistics. Certified nurse-midwives
have a cesarean rate of only 12 percent, compared to the national
average of 23 percent, according to the ACNM. Nurse-midwives also
have a vaginal birth rate after a previous cesarean of 69 percent,
compared to the national rate of 25 percent.
The different
philosophies, however, can create tensions in hospital delivery
rooms, Snell said. She gives her patients the choice of having
an IV, for example, but IVs are standard procedure for delivering
mothers in most hospitals, she said.
"There
seems to be almost a competition within our profession of nursing,"
said Snell, who runs an independent practice. "What I would
love to see are nurses who are receptive to nurse-midwifery."
Another challenge
for Snell is obtaining coverage for her services from insurance
companies. She has to turn away about 20 percent of her business
when patients discover providers will not reimburse her for services.
Although the
majority of nurse-midwives deliver in hospitals, about 1 percent
still specialize in home births. Becky Burpo, MSN, RN, CNM, hadn’t
planned to pursue this area—until she witnessed her first home
delivery.
Burpo had
worked as an RN in labor and delivery for 17 years when she decided
to return to school to study midwifery. She was a student when
her preceptor asked if she was interested in watching a birth
in the home.
"I was
expecting to see the mother in bed," Burpo said. "When
I got there, the woman was at 5 centimeters and fully clothed.
She went on a walk around the block!"
Burpo was
shocked when the nurse-midwife allowed the woman to go into the
backyard pool when she was at 7 centimeters. Burpo was so amazed
by the experience that she had trouble sleeping for a week, she
said.
"It’s
a very spiritual event," Burpo said. "All the family
is around crying, and you are there with them."
To prepare
for an emergency, long before the due date Burpo outlines a plan
for transportation to the nearest hospital. In the case of a cesarean,
for example, a physician takes over. She has had no emergency
transfers in her eight years of practice, though. One reason for
this may be that she carefully screens patients before she agrees
to perform a home delivery. She does not accept clients who have
had a cesarean or are unmotivated about taking care of themselves
through pregnancy with proper nutrition and exercise.
For Burpo,
one of the greatest challenges of home birthing is learning to
operate in an unfamiliar environment each time she delivers in
a new house. "You also drive all over creation," she
said.
Sister Angela
Murdaugh, RN, CNM, also has picked a less-traveled path in nurse-midwifery.
She runs a birth center in a rural area of Texas, and is among
the 2.4 percent of nurse-midwives who perform deliveries in birth
centers rather than hospitals, according to the ACNM.
Murdaugh opened
the Holy Family Birth Services center 19 years ago outside the
town of Weslaco at a time when pregnant women had to drive 25
miles to give birth at the nearest medical facility.
The majority
of her patients are Hispanic wives of field workers or people
who operate small businesses.
"I love
the pace here," she said, "and I love the people. They
value family so much."
She struggles,
though, to find physicians who will treat problems she detects
in her patients. One time, she performed a routine tuberculosis
test on a pregnant woman, and the patient tested positive.
Murdaugh couldn’t
find a nearby physician who would treat the woman, because she
was uninsured. About 80 percent of her patients aren’t insured.
Murdaugh receives
most of her compensation through grants, donations and sometimes
patients who perform jobs at the center in exchange for her services.
Murdaugh admits
that the small-town atmosphere has its drawbacks at times. She
misses the freedom to see quality theater productions, but she
wouldn’t give up the chance to work with the underprivileged.
"It’s
a source of great satisfaction," she said. "I like not
having bureaucracy and the fact that everyone knows your name."