Remember poring
over the college course catalog every semester, piecing together
a schedule of classes like a jigsaw puzzle? If the first class
on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays is at 7:40 a.m., there's room
for an elective at 9:40, which leaves an hour for lunch, study
and commuting to "Introduction to Something-or-Other"
at 12:40 and that dovetails into work at 3 p.m. Then on Tuesdays
and Thursdays
Pam Thomas,
RN, is missing those memories as she pursues a BSN degree at the
University of Kansas. But chances are a 7:40 wouldn't fit into
her schedule, nor would a 9:40.
There's the
matter of her job performing insurance assessments and benefit
determinations for residents of a long-term care facility, helping
her husband in the family business and home-schooling their 12-year-old
son. Not to mention that it's a real pain making it to lectures
and labs at the university. The medical center campus is half
a block from the Missouri state line in Kansas City, Kan., and
more than 400 miles east of Thomas' home in McDonald, Kan.
She was on
campus for the first time in mid-May for induction into Sigma
Theta Tau, the nursing honor society. "We are full-time farmers,"
Thomas said. Fortunately for her nursing career, though, the Internet
has plowed new ground in education. She may be isolated on the
prairie of western Kansas, but she also is among thousands of
students going online for college degrees.
"We bought
our computer 10 days before my first class," Thomas said.
"I was completely computer illiterate." But with the
staff of a help desk at the university and tutoring from her pastor
and a friend, she mastered the technical skills to use the Internet.
Now, at age 50, she has her sights set on becoming a family nurse
practitioner and doing it all online.
Forty-four
percent of two- and four-year institutions offer distance learning,
the U.S. Department of Education said in a report based on 1997-98
data, the latest available. The department's National Center for
Education Statistics pegged enrollment in college-credit online
courses at 1,343,580, up from 753,640 in the fall of 1995. Health
sciences is the third most popular curriculum, behind English/humanities/social
sciences and business, the report said.
"We don't
have any research yet to show that nursing courses online are
as good as-or better than-nursing courses face-to-face,"
said Thomas Nolan, Ph.D., RN, a professor at Sonoma State College
in Rohnert Park, Calif. "There's a lot of research, however,
showing that online education in the generic is at least as good
as if not superior to face-to-face," he said.
"People
who raise the argument that it's not as good assume that face-to-face
is for everybody. The face-to-face model was developed in the
1500s. It was a monastic model, frankly, that has not really changed
a whole lot since then. There are many learning styles."
Distance education
simply is different. Different for students, different for faculty,
different in its approach. But nursing school administrators agree
that it has irrevocably changed the face of nursing education.
It's here to stay and it's growing.
The University
of Kansas in 1998-three years after its first online nursing courses-phased
out its traditional RN-to-BSN program because of low enrollment
and now offers it exclusively online, said Helen Connors, Ph.D.,
RN, FAAN, associate dean of academic affairs. "When we had
a traditional RN-to-BSN, we had very few students," despite
attempts to bunch classes a couple of days a week to accommodate
working nurses. We couldn't afford to offer it in a traditional
classroom."
Online, however,
RN-to-BSN enrollment stands at nearly 100 students, up 53 percent
from last year, she said, not counting students taking prerequisites
but not yet admitted to the college of nursing.
Master's degree
courses are offered online and in the traditional setting, but
Connors said online classes fill up faster. For example, one online
course that has 31 students (the university anticipated 20) will
be offered in a traditional setting in the fall. As of late June,
only four students had registered for it.
Four community
colleges in Michigan are breaking ground, too, seeking approval
for what is believed to be the first entirely online associate
degree RN program. "We're the first ones to try to deal with
students who don't have any pre-licensure coming in," said
project manager Ann Ivers, MS, RN, of Northwestern Michigan College.
The schools-Northwestern
in Traverse City; Kellogg Community College in Battle Creek; Jackson
Community College in Jackson; and St. Clair County Community College
in Port Huron-have asked to start with 40 students beginning in
January.
"Some
students believe it's just going to be an easier way to do a nursing
program and that's not true," Ivers said. "If anything,
it's probably harder in terms of independence and their role in
it." Besides the academics, "We'll have four regional
labs available for practice of skills," she said. "There
will still be a hands-on component. In fact, it's as many hours
as it would be in a traditional program."
Online RN-to-BSN
programs typically handle clinicals with faculty-approved preceptors
wherever students happen to live and work.
For students
at every level, convenience is paramount. Online education gives
them the option of attending class, so to speak, at noon, 10 p.m.
or 4 a.m.-whenever it's convenient-and sometimes working several
weeks ahead of classmates. Such freedom, though, takes self-motivation
to keep from falling behind.
"We find
that most students keep up with the work," Connors said.
As a practical matter, schools almost universally keep online
curricula within the confines of semesters as opposed to being
completely learn-at-your-leisure.
Nine master's-prepared
medical center staff work with Kansas faculty to put courses online.
Together, they know the content, what the students are to accomplish
and how to make it happen on the computer. "They unleash
a lot of creativity," Connors said.
Computer-based
courses typically involve simulated cases, gaming, slide presentations,
discussions-real time and asynchronous-and exercises. In one exercise,
Connors said, students view computer screens of rhythm strips
and have to interpret the meanings. "We don't want to just
put text on a screen that they have to sit there and read,"
she said. "We don't want to [use] all video, either, because
that's passive learning."
Jan Martin,
Ph.D., RN, said that after teaching nursing research online at
the University of Northern Colorado in Greeley, she added an Internet
component to the on-campus offering because it encourages participation.
Those who tend to be quiet in class are absolutely invisible online
if they don't join in exercises, group projects and what are known
as "threaded discussions," in which students are required
to post comments and questions and further the conversation in
an electronic forum.
"Quiet
people can be quiet and the loud people are going to be loud no
matter what," Martin said. "On the Internet it doesn't
matter. It's a great equalizer in a lot of ways. By the end of
the semester, you say 'discuss' and everybody's doing it,"
rendering her start-of-the-semester mandate for participation
moot.
Sonoma State's
Nolan said he, too, finds that online students are more engaged
with course and content because "they have to be looking
at it and thinking about it all the time. I have their noses anchored
to a grindstone. The beauty of it is I can track at a moment's
notice every single person's performance and contribution."
There are
downsides to distance learning, however, and one is the same as
the benefit: class always is "percolating" as Nolan
puts it. Students who don't regularly "see" faculty
assume they always are available. When it comes to e-mail, which
along with message boards is how questions are handled, "They
want an answer right now, not tomorrow. It's a 24-7 model, that's
for sure."
Another drawback,
Nolan said, is that there is no substitute for face-to-face contact.
"Nursing
students like to hang around faculty offices and schmooze and
stand in the doorway while you're eating your sandwich and trying
to get something done and talk. Perhaps it's part of nursing's
caring. We facilitate it, and you can't do that online."
Furthermore,
"You can't see winks or raises of an eyebrow or tongue in
cheek. That's a major limitation."
But that doesn't
seem to interfere with students' opinions of courses, Connors
said.
"When
you ask them, 'All things being equal would you take a course
like this again?' most of them are saying, 'Oh, yes, you bet!'
and they'd recommend it to others."
Throughout
the country, nursing schools are finding their niches in distance
learning.
The majority
of Kansas' online learners live within 30 miles of campus. But
the BSN program has universal appeal because, although there is
a fee for "off-campus" classes, it is far less expensive
than out-of-state tuition. One student moved to Paris and continued
to attend the university as if she were on campus, Connors said.
The University
of Northern Colorado mainly bridged the Continental Divide with
its first class. Eight of 10 students were from the western slope.
But now in the fourth year and near its maximum enrollment of
25 students, it has crossed state lines.
"I'm
starting to interest people who are traveling nurses," Martin
said. "You know travelers always figure they can never go
back for their degree because they never stay anywhere long enough.
But they can keep doing this and be able to travel as they want
in their jobs," as long as they stay in one place long enough
to do their clinicals, she said.
California
State University, Dominguez Hills, is exploring the Internet as
a way of expanding its nursing program internationally. "We
have a significant number of students who are in the military
or some kind of overseas assignment," said Carole Shea, Ph.D.,
RN, FAAN, chair of nursing.
In the meantime,
Shea said, "I can see the live courses continuing with a
much more technological component."
Sixty percent
of the school's 1,100 baccalaureate and master's students have
expressed an interest in online courses, Shea said. "I think
our students are giving us the message that these online courses
are really serving their needs. I consider them pioneers."