Although an
assault may last only a matter of moments, workplace violence
often has lingering effects. "I still have little flashes,"
said Susan Schultheis, MSN, RN, a staff nurse in the medical intensive
care unit at Portland VA Medical Center in Oregon.
Although most
recent media stories of workplace violence depict assaults by
patients or visitors against nurses, occasionally the violence
occurs between health care professionals. Two years ago, after
Schultheis had a rancorous disagreement with a physician about
patient care, the physician erupted in anger, pinned Schultheis
against a wall and dragged her down the hall by her arm.
Although Schultheis
was able to break free fairly quickly, she’s still dealing with
the psychological scars. "When someone explodes in anger,
I have more of a fear-and-flight response," she said. "But
I recognize and control it."
She was able
to regain control by taking some time off, seeking counseling,
using some antidepressants and receiving "amazing" support
from her co-workers. "If my co-workers had not been so supportive,
I probably would have left nursing," Schultheis said.
No two people
respond exactly the same way in the aftermath of violence. But
experts agree that organizations need programs to help victims
and witnesses recuperate. Employee assistance programs, on-site
counseling and psychological and situational debriefings aid in
successful recovery, said Jane Lipscomb, Ph.D., RN, FAAN, associate
professor of nursing at the University of Maryland in Baltimore.
Psychological
debriefings allow survivors to talk with mental health experts
about what happened, and to discuss possible aftereffects, such
as sleeplessness, flashbacks or mind wandering, said Glenda Walker,
DSN, RN, director of nursing at Stephen F. Austin State University
in Nacogdoches, Texas.
Situational
debriefings focus on what could have been done differently to
prevent the incident without pointing fingers. Instead, participants
make suggestions to change policies or the environment.
Most important,
recovering nurses need to understand that even though they couldn’t
control that one violent event, they still can be in control in
the future "by taking a proactive approach, always being
aware of your surroundings," said Deborah DiBenedetto, MBA,
RN, president of the American Association of Occupational Health
Nurses.
A routine
end to a routine day was all Cathleen Shultz, Ph.D., RN, FAAN,
anticipated after finishing her shift at a metropolitan hospital
late one afternoon. Her goal was to beat the Atlanta traffic home.
But within a few moments, Shultz, dean of nursing at Harding University
in Searcy, Ark., was running for her life.
As she started
her solitary walk to her car, she quickly noticed the staccato
beat of unfamiliar footsteps keeping pace with her own, no matter
how she varied her gait. In a fear-induced rush of adrenaline,
she fled. Not until she was well within the security of the guarded
parking lot did she feel safe enough to turn around. By then,
the sound of soles on the asphalt had been replaced by the metallic
scrape of a 10-inch knife blade against the chain-link fence.
A man clad in a trench coat yelled to her as he flashed his weapon,
"It’s a good thing you got inside the gate, because look
what I had for you!"
Unfortunately,
Shultz’s day was more routine than many may think. Violence in
general is becoming commonplace in health care settings, and nurses
are particularly vulnerable. Almost two-thirds of hospitals are
in areas that have above average or average violent crime risk,
reported a study last year by the International Association for
Healthcare Security and Safety.
But the inside
of hospitals can be just as dangerous. Increased stress due to
lower staffing ratios and decreased insurance coverage, as
well as rampant drug and alcohol abuse, often translate into assaults,
beatings, stabbings, shootings or rapes in the facility.
The perpetrator
may be a stranger, a patient, a visitor or a co-worker. Although
traditionally emergency rooms and psychiatric settings have been
the most dangerous, no department is immune to violence.
"Now
it’s across the board, in every clinical area in the hospital,
clinics, any health care setting," said Cheryl Anderson,
Ph.D., MN, RN, an assistant professor in the school of nursing
at the University of Texas at Arlington.
Of the estimated
1,000 murders and 1.5 million assaults in the workplace every
year, about two-thirds occur in health care settings, said Anderson,
who has written magazine articles on workplace violence.
"Fifty
percent of the nursing population is affected by violence in the
workplace," DiBendetto said.
Reasons vary,
but "across the board, there’s more rage in America,"
said Tim Dimoff, president of SACS Consulting and Investigative
Services Inc., in Akron, Ohio. He has trained health professionals
on violence reduction and defusing techniques.
"Frustrations
are taken out against the primary caregiver," DiBenedetto
said. Nurses in particular are vulnerable, she said, because "we
tend to close our eyes to potential danger. We make exceptions
or allowances for behavior that would be intolerable in any other
environment."
Other violent
incidents could happen anywhere to anyone, but when a nurse nearly
is attacked, solutions are not far behind. But individuals alone
can’t control the problem. Organizations need to do their part
as well.
"You
can prevent a great amount of rage and violence by having a system
and policies and procedures in place to let people know they can’t
get away with it," Dimoff said. Visible security personnel,
immediate response to threats, well-lit walkways and the buddy
system go a long way toward deterring trouble.
Within the
last few years, Harrison Memorial Hospital in Bremerton, Wash.,
has taken extra security precautions to control increasing violence,
said Kathleen Sanford, RN, the organization’s vice president for
nursing. New hospital features include bulletproof glass, rebuilt
entrances to the ER to restrict access if necessary, and lock-down
features between the ER and the rest of the facility.
Security policies
include "Code 28," which summons a specialized team
24/7 to de-escalate violence at the first sign of trouble. All
employees receive safety training, updated annually, and assistance
in filing charges against instigators.
Although no
amount of preparation or precautions can make a setting immune
to violence, they can help minimize harm to staff and patients.
Nurses should not accept violence as an inevitable part of their
jobs, said Phil Burns, president of SyTech Research in Tulsa,
Okla. His company studies workplace violence in all arenas.
"Violence
is never acceptable. Period," he said.
Shultz knows
that firsthand. Unfortunately, her would-be assailant was never
caught, although she reported the incident immediately. Through
sheer nerve, she was able to go back to the parking lot, but she
never received any formal counseling to deal with the incident.
"The
world is not as naive a place after something like that,"
she said. But she retells her story frequently to teach violence
prevention and awareness to the next generation of nurses to make
sure they can avert a violent encounter.