"When
love blooms therein, the heart dances and tremor cordis is
upon me." So wrote Richard Selzer, MD, in his 1996 book of
essays, Mortal
Lessons: Notes on the Art of Surgery, to recognize the place
accorded the heart in our culture. Clichés such as "with
all my heart" bespeak this organ’s association with the site
of the genuine, irreducible self.
But
that association stems from a figure of speech, no? The heart is
a pump, a muscle a vital one, true, but no seat of emotion, intelligence
or identity in a literal sense.
Not
so fast, say the founders of the Institute of HeartMath, a nonprofit
research organization in Boulder Creek, Calif. Founded in the early
’90s, the center promotes the HeartMath System for stress management,
general health, anti-aging and other benefits, all predicated on
an understanding of the heart as an "intelligent" organ
with its own nervous system and hormone-producing capacities.
One
just has to harmonize heart/brain communication through "positive"
feelings such as appreciation, love and compassion.
But
skeptics should know that the concept of a "brainy" heart
stems from valid research, said Howard Martin, executive vice president
of HeartMath and co-author with Doc Childre of The
HeartMath Solution.
"The
heart sends out 40 to 60 times more electrical impulses than the
brain. It has 40,000 neurons," Martin said. "It doesn’t
just pump blood; it plays a role in controlling emotions, secreting
hormones. For thousands of years, people have written about the
heart as having intelligence maybe they were right. Sometimes modern
science produces what people already know."
Dianne
Ball, RN, and Joan Stephens, RN, know one thing: HeartMath saved
their jobs. The two nurses at Delnor-Community Hospital in Geneva,
Ill., were ready to call it quits to their nursing careers for familiar
reasons: stress, burnout, interpersonal and communication problems.
Ball,
who is now cardiac rehabilitation services director at Delnor, said
she heard about HeartMath at a convention, went to California for
the training and saw her problems in a new light.
"I
now had a different perspective, [along with] tools to break down
communication barriers and ways to handle stressors better. That’s
impacted my health."
Stephens,
director of home health care services at Delnor, concurred. "In
a stressful situation, when everything’s in your face, this system
gives you the ability to shift immediately to your heart, to calm
its rhythms with positive feelings and respond more appropriately
to a crisis."
Stephens
has been training the staff in HeartMath techniques. "Rather
than jump to conclusions, you can use this one-minute power tool
for internal balance, to listen intuitively, appreciate the core
values of a person," Stephens said.
Ball
and Stephens’ enthusiasm for the system, used by Fortune 100 companies,
the military and other settings, persuaded Delnor to spend $10,000
to certify them as HeartMath trainers and, starting last month,
to spend thousands more to train the staff. Delnor is the first
hospital to embrace the system on such a wide scale.
Through
techniques such as Freeze Frame and Heart Lock-In, Delnor’s staff
may communicate better, reduce personality conflicts and increase
productivity, Ball and Stephens said. They also can measure their
heart rates via Freeze-Framer software posted on the floor, which
graphically illustrates their heart rhythms.
"You
can actually see the results of your shift on the screen, right
there, in real time," Stephens said. "That’s a big convincer."
But
Ball’s use of HeartMath with her cardiac patients has impressed
her the most.
"Before,
they would seem to be doing everything right: cholesterol, diet,
exercise. But we weren’t focusing on stress, on the emotional aspects
that worsened their condition," she said. "Now they can
handle the stress better, and that’s impacting their health."
Lest
this sound like an infomercial, the wider medical community finds
HeartMath’s claims about improved blood pressure, anti-aging and
"little brains" in the heart inconclusive to put it gently.
This, despite publications such as the American Journal of Cardiology
featuring the institute’s research.
"There’s
no question that the heart and brain are connected and they exchange
impulses. And you can train your brain’s responses through meditation
or drugs. But most people would reject the idea of an ‘intellectual’
side to the heart," said William Harlan, MD, a cardiologist
and associate director for disease prevention at the National Institutes
of Health. "We have begun to appreciate that other parts of
the body produce important substances, like serotonin. But that
doesn’t mean the guts or the heart are intelligent. The brain is
still primary."
The
FDA has recognized neural pathways in the digestive tract an independent
"brain," if you will playing some role in irritable bowel
syndrome, but this only raises more questions about the interconnection
of physiology and psychology, said Joanne Spetz, research fellow
for medical technology at the Public Policy Institute of California.
"These
sorts of alternative medicine, usually written off as hokey, do
contribute to growing research that sees the body as more than just
a walking sack of chemicals," she said. "While inconclusive,
it shows how much we have to learn about the mysteries of the body."
Until
more studies and peer review, agrees Harlan, it’s just too early
to say despite all the wonderful claims.
But
Ball waves away criticisms of HeartMath as pseudoscience or at best a
placebo-type therapy.
"The
proof is in the pudding, so to speak," she said. "We use
it and it works."
It’s
an old debate: Where in the body does the "real me" reside?
In
his essay, Selzer reminds the reader that in a more "hepatic"
age, the ancient Greeks and Romans considered another organ the
site of human identity; only with the rise of anatomy studies was
"the liver toppled from its central role and the heart elevated
to the chair of emotions and intellect."
So
much the better. "Cross your liver" just doesn’t have
the same ring.
|