About
six months ago, top officials at San Angelo Community Medical Center
in Texas asked a committee of nurses what the hospital needed to
do to keep them from leaving. Almost no one mentioned money. Instead,
as administrators listened slack-jawed, nurse after nurse talked
about broken equipment, inflexible schedules, confusion among new
graduates, patients rushed through the system and constant work
with little recognition.
"Treat
us as people. That was what a lot of the complaints came down to,"
said Vicki Crouch, RN, a staff nurse at San Angelo who is on the
committee. "Give us what we need to do our jobs the way we
want to do them."
Flexibility
and listening
Nurses
across the country sound a lot like singer Aretha Franklin demanding
R-E-S-P-E-C-T. A recent study by the American Organization of Nurse
Executives found that along with "competitive compensation,"
nurses want schedules that allow them to balance their personal
and professional lives, support for continuing education and managers
who respect and listen to them.
After
cutting staff and eliminating mentoring programs in the 1980s, hospitals
are reaping a bitter harvest of overworked staffs, distrust of management
and inexperienced nurses burnt out from taking on too much too quickly,
said Kay McVay, RN, president of the California Nurses Association.
Add
that to a nursing shortage and a host of new opportunities for people
with nursing degrees from consulting to home care to the Internet and
many hospital nurses are deciding they don’t have to take it anymore.
"I’d
had it," said Sheryl Picco, RN, of Pleasant Hill, Calif., a
28-year veteran of acute care who left a Northern California hospital
in March. Picco, now a legal nurse consultant and part-time teacher,
said her emergency room nursing staff was cut from four to three
and given extra duties without thanks or acknowledgement. "The
reason I stayed as long as it did was because I loved the patients
and I loved the people on my shift," she said.
"Something
has got to change," she added.
Writing
on the wall
Hospital
administrators acknowledge they need to find ways to keep nurses
happy. Along with promises of signing bonuses, recruitment advertisements
for nurses use words such as "career satisfaction," "family
atmosphere" and "teamwork."
"It’s
hard to develop good team spirit when your players are rotating
off the team all the time," AONEpresident Lois L. Kercher,
DNSc, RN, said. Nurse managers need to let the nurses who work for
them know that their work and opinions are valued, Kercher said.
They should have as much input as possible into decisions that affect
them. For instance, she encourages each of the units at her hospital
in Virginia to arrange their own shifts.
"My
time schedules look like a patchwork quilt, but that’s something
that gives nurses satisfaction. They feel they can control their
schedules to meet their own needs," she said.
Many
hospitals have started or reinstated orientation programs for new
graduates to ease the transition from nursing school to the hospital
floor. Idealistic young nurses often have a romanticized view of
hospital work, said Julie Fairman, Ph.D., RN, FAAN, an associate
professor at the School of Nursing at the University of Pennsylvania
in Philadelphia.
Mentoring
programs like the one at the University of Pennsylvania Health System
match new graduates with experienced clinical nurses who can help
them with anything from patient care to dealing with common workplace
problems.
Crouch
said administrators at San Angelo seem to have taken to heart the
lessons of their meetings with the nurse committee. They hold regular
staff appreciation buffets catered by the administrators themselves and
prize drawings. They’ve established an employee recognition program
and mentoring program for new nurses. They are making sure broken
computers and machines get fixed. And one day when Crouch’s day-surgery
unit had an unusually heavy patient load, the administration brought
in pizza because they knew no one would have time to go out for
lunch.
Most
important, Crouch said, they seem to listen and follow through when
she or another nurse comes to them with a problem. "I’m to
the point where I trust them," she said. "We’ve got people
at the top who are doing whatever they can to do what’s right for
the patients and what’s right for the employees."
Sounds
like a recipe for retention.
|