|
Washington
(H24N).
A new report warns against modifying human genes to eliminate inherited
diseases or enhance abilities.
The
report, which was put together by a panel commissioned by the American
Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS), was released
yesterday. Called "Human Inheritable Genetic Modifications:
Assessing Scientific, Ethical, Religious, and Policy Issues,"
the report concludes that inheritable genetic modifications, or
IGM, "cannot be carried out safely or responsibly on human
beings."
In
theory genetic manipulation in humans could result in "designer
children," whose modified genes would make them and any future
offspring taller, more athletic, more beautiful or more intelligent.
IGM could also be employed in theory to rid a family of genes known
to cause inherited diseases. But the panel warns that the risks
involved far outweigh any benefits at this time, suggesting that
"human trials of inherited genetic changes should not be initiated
until techniques are developed that meet agreed upon standards for
safety and efficacy."
The
panel says media reports often focus on the successes of genetic
experiments on animal test subjects and gloss over the spectacular
failures such research encounters along the way. Those failures
include gross physical distortions, major birth defects and fatal
abnormalities that may be acceptable to some when they occur with
test animals. The report suggests society would not accept the same
experimentation with humans.
The
AAAS panel consisted of scientists, lawyers, ethicists and representatives
from several religious faiths. The group considered the issues involved
over a two-and-half-year period before reaching its results.
|