|
About 5,000
new graduates join the nursing profession in California each year.
In rough numbers, about 4,200 are from associate degree programs
and 800 graduate from bachelor’s degree programs. The highest percentage
of these nurses joins our workforce in June.
Within the first
year of employment, depending on whose numbers you believe, upward
of 80 percent to 90 percent of new graduates will leave their first
job. This is not a new phenomenon; high turnover of new graduates
has been with us a long time. We should all be embarrassed by this
statistic. It will take all of us working together to change it.
Both education
and practice share responsibility in affecting the new graduate’s
first job experience. Things need to change in the work environment
that receives new graduates as well as the educational system that
prepares them.
A significant
gap still exists between the structured clinical experiences of
the student and the real-life work experiences of a practicing nurse.
It still is rare for a student to graduate after accepting a realistic
patient care assignment. Faculty also have an important role in
developing a student’s expectations and impressions of the workplace.
These are not always positive or accurate. Student rotations should
be altered to provide a more realistic experience of bedside nursing.
In turn, hospitals
and more experienced co-workers have unrealistic expectations of
new graduates and put them in positions of responsibility far ahead
of their time. The growing shortage of nurses is likely to exaggerate
this problem.
Experienced
nurses, tapped as preceptors, are not always prepared to provide
the needed structure and support to new nurses, or given the necessary
time from their normal work responsibilities. The sink-or-swim attitude
still is a common experience. Managers need to ensure that new graduates
are not pushed beyond their abilities in the first year of practice.
Many nursing experts have suggested that a required, BRN-approved
pre-licensure internship before entry into practice would provide
a buffer to ensure that new nurses acquire early experience in a
supportive and structured manner.
While new nurses
are increasingly savvy and seek out employment where there are educational
resources and preceptor support designed specifically for the new
graduate, they may not be able to assess the variables that separate
the "adequate" from the "exceptional" new graduate
environments. Let’s just say that not all new graduate programs
are created equal.
Often, the promise
of a structured new graduate program is nothing more than a slightly
extended orientation period. However, California does have some
model programs that have demonstrated excellent outcomes with high
new grad retention rates. These are the programs we should showcase
and replicate in other settings.
To improve new
graduate retention, the work environment must improve as well. This
remains the most significant challenge facing health care today.
Those of us at the bedside are not always the most supportive of
new graduates either. As nurses, we should be willing to make the
greatest investment of all in new nurses. We have the most to gain
from their success and presence at the bedside.
While it does
require significant investment of resources to provide the necessary
support for new graduates, it is money well spent. Responsible employers
should not hire new graduates unless they are willing to make the
investment in education and support in a professional clinical practice
environment with the requisite resources for new graduates. As a
profession, we can afford only the best and most supportive experiences
for our new colleagues.
What
do you think?
Email us at
editor@nurseweek.com
|