The
end of life. The right to die with dignity. How often do
we hear these phrases and even experience death with loved
ones, yet there is no magical way to assure that each person’s
wishes are respected and carried out.
My first
painful memorable experience came as a young nurse at a
veterans hospital in Madison, Wis. I treated a patient who
had no lung capacity left due to tuberculosis and was kept
comfortable with nasal catheter oxygen. I cared for "Sir
Cedric," as I fondly called him, with precise directions
from him on how to tape and administer the oxygen. As I
cared for him, fed him and bathed him for more than three
months, I came to know him and his wishes. Finally, the
end was near, and as the p.m. charge nurse, I called the
officer of the day to the ward. He ordered me to bring the
cardiac arrest tray. In those days, a long needle was placed
directly in the patient’s heart and adrenalin was administered.
As I
held his wrist, taking his pulse, I followed the physician’s
orders and watched as Cedric responded and gave me the most
awful look: "Brownie, how could you do this to me?"
He did not speak, but his eyes told me how he felt and I
will never forget that look as he died. I returned to the
glass-enclosed nurses station and yelled at the physician
for disrupting his right to die with dignity. The physician
said he followed the Hippocratic Oath and had I told him
of my patient’s pathophysiological condition, he would not
have performed the procedure. I have never "followed"
a physician’s orders since and strongly advocate interpreting
orders based on nursing knowledge of the patient’s data
and diagnosis.
Years
later, as a patient care administrator, I was making patient
rounds and saw a young nurse step out of a patient’s room
crying. I asked her what was wrong. It was her first death,
so we did the final care together and we talked about dying
and that it is all right to care.
Death
is part of the continuum of life. Sometimes death occurs
when least expected, as in an accident or trauma. Preparation
is seldom considered and the family needs are great for
physical and emotional support. Nurses are the closest to
the caring and are rarely allowed enough time to care for
the family. Then the nurse involved suffers the loss, too.
A living
will should ensure the right to die with dignity and determine
the end-of-life wishes not to use extraordinary extension-of-life
procedures, but this is not always observed by the physicians
who admit patients, especially in emergency situations.
I took
my father’s last apical heartbeats at home as he died of
lung cancer, but stupidly called for an ambulance to transport
his body to be pronounced dead. What a mistake. I rode in
the ambulance to the hospital, and he was admitted to the
emergency room of a big, city hospital where I was a resident
in hospital administration. In the waiting room, I suddenly
realized that they would not know that he had died of lung
cancer. I ran to the room as they were hooking him up to
everything and I pulled the plugs. He did die with dignity
at home, with loving family at his side, but to this day
my brother feels he did not die at home.
What
a family perceives to be the wishes of the patient is of
utmost importance. While we are busy being professional
and efficient, we neglect to consider the impact on those
around us.
Whether
a neophyte nurse, a family member or even a young physician,
we all share in the experience of death and dying. Nurses
and physicians have the unique opportunity to enable all
people to experience the end of life with compassion and
dignity.
Many
at the end of life, especially the elderly and homeless,
have no family to care for them, so we must be there. It
is my life and it is my right to choose. Each nurse accepts
the responsibility to uphold that right as the practice
of nursing demands.